
Matthew D. Elshiaty
Attorney — Member
(304) 225-0970 ext 326 | Download V-card
“Kay Casto & Chaney lawyers are well respected throughout the state.”
- Chambers and Partners USA

Profile
Matthew D. Elshiaty is a Member of Kay Casto & Chaney PLLC and practices in the firm’s Morgantown office. He represents businesses, insurers, municipalities, public officials, and individuals in civil litigation and related advisory matters.
Mr. Elshiaty’s litigation practice includes trucking and motor-vehicle defect claims, product liability, construction defects, insurance disputes, commercial claims, and employment matters. He works with clients from the early investigation and assessment of risk through discovery, expert development, mediation, trial, and appeal, combining careful attention to technical evidence and causation with practical advice about cost, exposure, and resolution.
As counsel to West Virginia municipalities, Mr. Elshiaty advises on governance, contracts, procurement, employment, regulatory matters, and claims against public bodies and officials. He also represents clients in state and federal court, including civil-rights litigation involving municipal liability and immunity.
Mr. Elshiaty has been named the Best Lawyers® 2027 “Lawyer of the Year” for Litigation – Construction and the 2026 “Lawyer of the Year” for Personal Injury Litigation – Defendants in Morgantown.
Before entering private practice, Mr. Elshiaty held analytical and supervisory roles in behavioral healthcare. That experience informs the clear, responsive counsel he provides to clients facing complex legal and operational decisions.
Education
| West Virginia University Bachelor of Arts, English and Political Science Concentration in American Literature and Writing Concentration in Legislature and Public Policy |
2009 |
| West Virginia University College of Law Doctor of Jurisprudence CALI Award, Contracts Associate Editor/Executive Publications Editor: West Virginia University Law Review |
2014 |
| Teaching Assistant: AEP Summer Law Institute West Virginia University College of Law |
|
| Research Assistant: West Virginia University College of Law Dean Gregory Bowman |
Practice Areas
- Litigation
- Commercial Litigation
- Insurance Litigation
- Product Liability – Plaintiffs and Defendants
- Trucking and Motor-Vehicle Defect Claims
- Construction-Defect Litigation
- Civil-Rights Defense
- Government
- Municipal Law
- Representation of Public Bodies and Officials
- Government Contracts and Procurement
- Business Services
- Construction Law
- Employment Law – Counseling and Litigation
- Insurance Law
- Commercial
- Contracts
- Business Disputes
- Real Estate
- Commercial Real Estate and Leasing
Experience
| Member: Kay Casto & Chaney PLLC, Morgantown Represents businesses, insurers, municipalities, public officials, and individuals in state and federal litigation, including trucking and motor-vehicle defect claims, product liability, construction defects, insurance and commercial disputes, employment claims, and civil-rights litigation. Provides ongoing municipal counsel on governance, contracts, procurement, employment, regulation, and claims. |
2014 – Present |
| Judicial Clerkship: Circuit Court of Monongalia County Honorable Russell M. Clawges, Jr. |
|
| Valley Healthcare System, Morgantown Financial Analyst; Service Coordination Supervisor; Therapeutic Consultant; Service Coordinator Held analytical and supervisory positions in a regulated behavioral-health setting before entering private practice. |
Involvement
- Member, Board of Governors: Defense Trial Counsel of West Virginia (2021 – Present)
- Member, CLE Commission: West Virginia State Bar (2024 – Present)
- Member, Animal Law Commission: West Virginia State Bar (2024 – Present)
Awards and Honors
- 2027 Best Lawyers® “Lawyer of the Year,” Litigation – Construction, Morgantown
- 2026 Best Lawyers® “Lawyer of the Year,” Personal Injury Litigation – Defendants, Morgantown
- The Best Lawyers in America® (2027): Litigation – Construction; Personal Injury Litigation – Defendants
- Rising Star – West Virginia Super Lawyers (2019 – 2024)
